Indirect cooling technology optimizes fertilizer production and quality
The importance of fertilizers to the world economy can hardly be overstated and the growth in fertilizer consumption since the 1960s has been impressive. By supplying crops with essential nutrients, fertilizers facilitate efficient use of land and water. In many developing countries the supply of fertilizer is as important as the supply of food itself, and regardless of market conditions, the need for high yields and increased crop production remains a priority.
China leads the world in fertilizer consumption followed by India and the United States. In Canada, one of the world’s smaller markets, farmers spend over $2 billion a year on fertilizers.
In line with growing environmental awareness and in order to optimize outcomes, the industry is working to reduce emissions, improve operational practices, and restructure existing plants to maximize production.
The challenge with cooling fertilizer
Within the fertilizer industry, an essential element of successful production is ensuring the product is stored and packaged at an appropriate temperature. Given the hygroscopic nature of fertilizer prills and granules, elevated temperatures can quickly translate into caking during storage, packaging and bulk transportation. When product quality is compromised by caking it results in breakage and handling difficulties which translate into a lower selling price and dissatisfied customers.
Two current market trends contribute to the importance of ensuring fertilizer is sufficiently cooled. One is the drive to increase production within existing facilities. This can result in product leaving the prill tower or cooler and arriving at the warehouse with an elevated temperature that consequently results in caking.
The second trend is the move to produce bigger prills and granules. The problem here is that bigger prills do not cool as much in the prill tower. Furthermore, there is a larger temperature gradient within the prill or granule itself. The outside cools quickly while the inside maintains both a higher temperature and a higher moisture content.
In storage, heat transfer occurs between the surface and the core of the granules, until the overall product temperature reaches equilibrium. The same process occurs between the centre and outer layers of bulk product. As the heat from the centre is transferred to the surface, the increased surface temperature allows evaporated water in the surrounding air to migrate to the product causing caking to occur.
Conventional fertilizer coolers
To ensure sufficient cooling and avoid caking in the fertilizer cooler, product temperature must be controlled either by installing an additional cooler in granulation plants or adding a fertilizer cooler to prilling plants where the original design did not to include a cooler.
For example, the majority of urea prill plants do not have a separate cooler after the prill tower which, in the original design, was high enough and had sufficient air to cool the prills to an acceptable temperature for storage. This situation changes when plant capacity is increased – a common scenario given the development of innovative technologies for increasing plant production. What occurs is that the increased capacity reaches a bottleneck at the prill tower because the fertilizer cooler capacity is essentially fixed by the height of the tower.
To deal with the increased capacity, a cooling stage is required. For many years, the standard choice in fertilizer cooling were moving bed heat exchangers such as rotary drum or the fluid bed fertilizer cooler. Yet when retrofitting an existing plant to facilitate increased production and larger prill and granule size, these options present a number of challenges.
Conventional fertilizer cooling technologies involve direct contact with high volumes of air which can impact product quality. Rotary drums and fluid beds come with high installation and operating costs. In addition, theyare often not suited to space restrictions within existing plants, particularly given the inclusion of expanded air handling and wet scrubbing systems that these technologies require.
Innovative fertilizer cooler technology
In the early 1990s, faced with the high cost of retrofitting a fluid bed fertilizer cooler for use in its plant near Calgary, an international fertilizer company developed a simple and elegant heat exchange technology based on a plate-based vertically orientated design that has come to be recognized within the fertilizer industry as one of the most significant technological developments of the last few years.
Solex technology combines the science of mass flow with the thermal efficiency of plate heat exchange design. In the MBHE, bulk solids pass in mass flow through vertical banks of stainless steel plates. Cooling water flows through the plates to cool the material by conduction. The water is circulated through the plates in counter-flow for enhanced thermal efficiency.
The indirect plate heat exchanger design means air is not used in the cooling process, a feature that both increases product quality and reduces installation and operating costs.
A mass flow discharge device controls the product flow rate through the exchanger. The product moves slowly by gravity through the unit to create sufficient residence time to achieve the required cooling.
A level control system ensures the fertilizer cooler operates at its optimum configuration.
Over the past 30 years, Solex fertilizer cooling technology has been successfully used to cool the full ranges of fertilizers from urea granules and prills to ammonium nitrate and CAN, NPKs, MAP, DAP, TSP and ammonium sulphate. Certain details are altered to allow for the differing properties of different products, but the principles of operation remain the same. For example, in urea prill plants, Solex's MBHE technology is installed after the prill tower.
Today, with more than 190 installations around the world, Solex's heat exchange technology offers improved product quality and stable temperatures at lower capital and operating costs.
Lower storage temperatures
Fertilizer producers need to be confident that material temperatures will meet their optimum storage requirements. As world leaders in the science of bulk solids heat exchange, Solex developed its own proprietary thermal software program to provide customers with accurate predictions of final product temperatures and guaranteed thermal performance.
The product is lab tested to evaluate thermal properties and flow characteristics. Then the modeling software, ThermaPro, performs detailed calculations based on material thermal properties and process requirements including the fertilizer’s bulk density, specific heat, thermal conductivity, input temperature and flow rate. The results of this modeling accurately predict how long prills or granules need to stay in the fertilizer cooler to reach the desired discharge temperature.
Based on the modeling program, the heat exchanger plates are positioned such that fertilizer flows through the cooler by gravity with a velocity that achieves the required residence time for sufficient and even cooling. The typical residence time is five to 10 minutes. The uniform product flow combined with long residence times enables even temperature distribution in the product as it passes through the Solex MBHE technology, producing remarkably stable and uniform final product temperatures.
Improved product quality
While increasing production, it is important to ensure that product quality remains high. When compared with the conventional technology of the rotary drum and fluid bed fertilizer coolers, the Solex fertilizer cooler offers advantages that contribute to improved product quality.
Typical fluid bed or rotary drum fertilizer cooler technology employs large volumes of air blown directly across the product and one drawback of this approach is that when air comes into direct contact with the product it introduces the risk of moisture content changes.
Unlike conventional technology, Solex's MBHE technology does not use air in the cooling process. This eliminates the risk of prills or granules absorbing moisture from saturated air. It also eliminates emissions, dust, fines and odors, as well as requiring significantly less energy than those technologies that use air.
Within Solex's MBHE technology, a mass flow discharge feeder regulates flow rate and creates uniform product velocity through the cooler. The product moves slowly under gravity. The flow pattern is laminar and there is no mechanical handling and moving of the particles, rendering the cooler ideal for soft and friable grades.
Tests have shown no measurable quantity of fines are created as the product flows through the cooler and the slow material movement avoids any product degradation and dust formation. This gentle product handling prevents product abrasion and degradation and produces a superior final product.
Lower installation costs
When analyzing the comparative cost of fertilizer cooling technologies, it is essential to include the entire system. For example, with a fluid bed fertilizer cooler, the air handling equipment required by the system includes fans, air chiller, air pre-heater, scrubber and ancillary equipment, and large diameter ducting to accommodate the high volume of air employed in the cooling process. As well as the cost involved, this equipment occupies a significant amount of space within a production facility and is often difficult to accommodate within an existing plant.
With Solex MBHE technology, installed capital costs are reduced due to the elimination of air handling equipment. The cooling water pump and piping required are not of significant size or cost. No air conditioning unit is required to produce dry and cool air, and no additional or new wet scrubber system is needed.
The vertical configuration of the technology makes the design both compact and modular. The compact installation footprint makes this design easy to integrate into existing plants and ideal for de-bottlenecking, revamps and capacity increases. In addition, the modular design means additional heat exchanger plates can be stacked if increased thermal capacity is required in the future.
While many variables can impact on the final capital cost, several case studies have demonstrated that the installation cost of a Solex cooling system generally runs at least 30 per cent lower than the cost of installing a fluid bed cooler.
Solex technology offers lower operating costs
The energy required to operate a fluid bed fertilizer cooler and the ancillary equipment it entails is significant. Use of a fluid bed cooler typically requires two large horsepower fans: first, a forced draft fan is needed to supply air to the cooler; and second, an induced draft fan is required following the scrubber. Additional energy draws in a fluid bed system include the air chiller and air pre-heater.
On the other hand, Solex technology has very low energy consumption. In fertilizer applications, the cooler constitutes only a small additional load on the existing cooling water system. The cooling water pump, bucket elevator and purge air system all have low horsepower requirements. With thermally high efficiency and a large capacity of up to 150 tph in a single cooler, Solex MBHE technology typically saves four to five kW.h/tonne compared to a fluid bed system, operating with as much as 90 per cent lower energy costs.
Operating costs of Solex MBHE technology are further reduced by the ease of cleaning and maintaining the system. Large hinged doors on the back of the cooler give full access to the plate banks which are configured to enable easy access for inspection and cleaning.
Cleaning is done by washing with water and drying with a counter-current of warm air. Typically the exchanger can be washed and dried in a four-to-eight-hour period, easily fitting within a normal plant maintenance schedule. The design makes it possible for single plates to be isolated or replaced if required. The simple system with few moving parts translates into minimal mechanical maintenance requirements.
Solex fertilizer cooling technology — an ideal solution
Within the fertilizer industry, the drive to increase production capacity and the market trend towards producing bigger prills and granules has made it more challenging for plants to sufficiently cool their product. Nonetheless, adequate cooling remains key to maintaining product quality and preventing caking and subsequent problems with customer dissatisfaction.
Solex's innovative MBHE technology offers an attractive alternative to what has been the standard choices of rotary drum or fluid bed cooler. Recognized within the fertilizer industry as one of the most significant developments in recent years, the fertilizer cooling solutions guarantees final product temperatures and does so at much lower capital and operating costs than standard cooling technology.
As world leaders in the science of bulk solids heat exchange, Solex combines the principles of mass flow of bulk solids with the science of indirect heat transfer. Solex MBHE technology is supported by extensive testing and development and uses proprietary thermal modeling software to accurately predict temperatures resulting in a design that ensures remarkably stable and uniform final product temperatures.
Unlike other cooler choices, the Solex system does not require large volumes of air and instead allows gravity to do the work, greatly reducing power consumption as well as eliminating emissions, dust, and odors.
In addition, the gentle product flow prevents product abrasion and degradation and produces a superior final product. Experience in more than sixty fertilizer plants around the world has demonstrated that, in comparison with conventional technology, Solex MBHEs generally costs 30 per cent less to install and, given its high efficiency and low energy consumption, delivers operating costs that are as much as 90 per cent lower.
With vertical configuration and compact design, the Solex system is easy to integrate into existing plants. Taken together, these advantages make the Solex fertilizer cooler an ideal solution for the challenge of increasing capacity while turning out a high quality product.
This entry was last updated on 2022-9-9
Return to Articles